Abby or Emma?

Okay, Angela and I were commenting on differences and similarities between Amelia and Abigail.
In the vigor of our discussion we went “back to the tape” and what we found surprised us.

Let’s just put it this way…if we had them at the same time we are SURE we would be able to tell them apart.

So, would you like to take the Pepsi challenge? Both of these pictures have one of Abby and one of Emma. Just guessing and you have a 50% chance of getting each one right…but I want to know why you make your choice.

AEZ_AMZ_Compare

AEZ_AMZ_Compare

7 thoughts on “Abby or Emma?”

  1. Oh my goodness! They look SO alike! I think 2B is definately Abby…something about that bottom lip but I’m only basing this on the tons of pics I’ve seen at work hehe.

    My best guess on the first match is 1A but this one seems much harder. Then again I could be wrong with both guesses.

    Like

  2. Since I have not seen Amelia with her eyes open for more than a few seconds, and I have never seen her mouth open, it is difficult for me, but I will venture a guess:

    Abby is 1A and 2A. Amelia is 1B and 2B. Amelia is definitely 2B, but I’m keeping the reason I know to myself. It’s something I spotted when I held her.

    Like

  3. I think 1B and 2B is Emma (I have not seen Emma yet) because on the pictures 1B and 2B have a copyright date on the bottom.

    Like

  4. I am not sure which is which, but they are definitely yours and definitely sisters!! And both adorable, of course.

    Like

  5. I noticed the date-mark in the lower left corner of each of Amelia’s pictures. That is cheating, I think.
    Lief, I’m sure, if you had thought about it you would have erased that tell-tale distinction. Then I would not have had a clue!!
    GGG.

    Like

Leave a reply to Great Grumpy G Cancel reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.